To address the concerns of investors that mutual funds are not adaptable enough to hold their own in a down market, a number of funds have taken a more dynamic approach to portfolio allocation and have begun to time the market by shifting in between cash and regular investments on a frequent basis. The managers of these funds claim to outsmart the volatility of the market.
This strategy has worked for some funds, such as Ivy Asset Strategy, which has made 14.9% annually for the five years ended this November (about 14% above the S&P 500). For other funds, attempts to time the market have led to increased volatility. For example, the Encompass Fund used the strategy of jumping in between allocation to cash and allocation to investments. It fell 62% last year and gained 110% this year.
Additional problems with the timing the market as a mutual fund are higher transaction costs due to the increase in trading and the possibility that the fund goes to cash before a market rally.
Regardless, these types of funds add some much-needed variety to the predominately buy-and-hold mutual fund market and should be considered in a down market for investors that don’t actively manage their portfolio.
-Erik Ringo – Group 11
